Plone 3 Intranets Review
Víctor Fernandez de Alba
When Packt asked me to review this book I have to honestly say that I wasn't looking forward to it. Plone as a product has a notorious track record for what I believe to be not the friendliest or most accessible documentation. Regardless of it's technical superiority and usability, it's a glaring deficiency. This is getting better with time but there is still a lot of work to do. Unfortunately my apprehension was filled with curiosity and I agreed to do so at one of the busiest times for me. That and the fact that instead of going on another tirade about documentation it would probably be useful to use my own guidelines in reviewing the book.
Nutshell for the impatient.
For those of you that cannot wait, have ADD, or TLDR syndrome here's a short summary. Actually, this may come as a shock but I really enjoyed the book. My initial wanton and disregard was primarily for Chapter 8 but clearly it was simply due to context. Packt should really not use that as a sample chapter for this book, it's a complete turn off for several reasons. I will pass that gripe along. That said, there are some tidbits in this book that really make it a good reference manual and a keeper for at least a little while. In regard to technical documentation that means it's something you probably want on your shelf if you're doing anything with Plone and intranets in the forseeable future. Quite frankly the book should be updated in minor fashion with a subsequent release for Plone 4 as not much has changed and it will help to get the book in hands of more new administrators and users of Plone. With some very minor changes this book could be called Plone 4 Intranets. This issue was most likely do to time constraints as Plone 4 has only recently been released. The intended audience for this book is administrators or new users who tend to do their own administration and I think it's successful in reaching that audience. That said on a scale of 1 - 10 I give the book a strong 7.
Chapter 1
The introduction gives a good general background to Plone and how it came into existence. Discussing the excellent security track record of the CMS and it's general history up until present. It then begins to segue into the more complicated but powerful features of Plone. Workflow, States and Transitions. This chapter also covers and introduces Python and ZODB (Zope Object Database) and why they are useful not only to Plone but to the entire content management space. It's short-and-sweet providing just enough information and background to make it useful to the reader. There is also a nice overview of the Plone community which introduces the reader to the entire community with a great handshake and welcome that is actually quite refreshing. An introduction on the fine line between extranet and intranets and how the spaces merge in some use case is a great cap for this chapter.
Plone and div blocking
Excuses
I haven't written any functional tutorial or such for Plone in a while. I'm working on a paper involving openid and started some work on an introduction to object and dynamic publishing that I need more time to work on, have random other things moving and etc excuses here. Something quick and useful in the meantime I suppose.
What is div blocking?
Div blocking is what I'm calling the process of returning a CoookedBody() back to your template into a specific html div. It's not specific to plone and it's a simple and straight-forward method many Plone developers call on. The idea is that you want to be able to return a section of html back into your overall template using a "Page" or "Document" content type. A simple use case for this is when you want to allow content-editors a chance to change something in the overall webpage using the standard Plone page content type. No sense in creating a new content-type just to return some formatted structured text. The end result is that you would like the final rendered html from that page to fit in-between <div></div> tags and for the overall look to leave your layout alone.